Every Repetition Tells Me Something (Coaching Principle 5)

Why evaluating movement and developing movement don't have to be separate activities.

By Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

When I watch an athlete perform a drill, I'm not simply looking to see whether they completed it.

I'm watching how they accomplished it.

What did they do when the movement began?

How did they organize their body?

What happened when they encountered the movement problem the drill was designed to create?

Those observations tell me something about how the athlete is currently performing the task.

At the same time, the athlete is gaining experience performing that movement.

The athlete is practicing, and I'm evaluating. Both can happen during the same repetition.

This is an important part of how I approach the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

A Drill Can Serve More Than One Purpose

It's common to think of evaluation and training as separate activities.

First, we evaluate the athlete.

Then, based on what we find, we begin training.

There are situations where that separation makes sense. Formal performance testing, for example, may require standardized procedures and specific measurements.

But not every coaching evaluation needs to be a formal test.

During regular training, I can learn a great deal by observing how an athlete responds to a particular movement problem.

A drill gives the athlete something to accomplish.

The athlete attempts to accomplish it.

Their response gives me information that can guide what happens next.

Meanwhile, the athlete has had another opportunity to experience and practice the movement.

The drill becomes both a training opportunity and a source of information for the coach.

Completing the Drill Isn't the Whole Story

An athlete can complete a drill without necessarily demonstrating the movement characteristics I intended to develop.

Another athlete might struggle to complete the same drill but demonstrate useful elements of the intended movement.

If I evaluate only whether the drill was completed, I may miss those distinctions.

That's why I want to understand how the athlete solved the movement problem.

Consider a drill that requires an athlete to initiate forward movement from a particular starting position.

The athlete may successfully move forward.

But I still want to observe how they initiated that movement.

What happened to their body position?

How did they transition out of the starting position?

How did they organize the movements that followed?

These observations may help me determine whether the athlete is addressing the movement objective of the drill.

I'm not necessarily looking for every athlete to move identically.

I'm looking for movement characteristics that are relevant to the purpose of the task.

Successful completion tells me something. How the athlete accomplished it may tell me more.

Observe, Decide, and Repeat

The coaching process doesn't end after one repetition.

I create a movement problem and observe the athlete's response.

Based on what I see, I decide what should happen next.

Sometimes I may adjust the starting position.

Sometimes I may change an instruction or modify a task demand.

Sometimes I may provide feedback about a specific movement characteristic.

And sometimes I may simply ask the athlete to perform the drill again.

Then I observe the next attempt.

Did the athlete respond differently?

Did the change help them accomplish the intended task?

Did the athlete find another way to organize the movement?

Do I need more information before making another decision?

This creates an ongoing process of observation, coaching decisions, practice, and reassessment.

The process isn't necessarily identical for every athlete or every repetition.

But the objective remains consistent: use what I observe to guide the athlete's next opportunity to perform the movement.

Each repetition can inform the next coaching decision.

Not Every Repetition Needs a Correction

One of the mistakes I try to avoid is assuming that every movement difference requires immediate verbal feedback.

An athlete may be encountering an unfamiliar movement problem.

Their first attempt may be awkward or incomplete.

That doesn't automatically mean I need to tell them how to perform the movement.

Sometimes they need another opportunity to experience the task.

As they repeat the drill, they may become more familiar with its demands and begin organizing their movement differently.

In those situations, allowing additional repetitions without changing the task may be an appropriate coaching decision.

That doesn't mean I should ignore persistent problems.

It also doesn't mean that repetition alone will always produce improvement.

If the athlete continues to struggle, or if their movement consistently fails to address the purpose of the drill, I may need to intervene.

But I want that intervention to have a reason.

The fact that I observed something doesn't automatically mean I need to correct it.

Sometimes the most useful decision is to allow the athlete another attempt.

Evaluation Doesn't Always Tell Me Why

Observing movement gives me information, but it doesn't necessarily explain the underlying cause of what I see.

Suppose an athlete has difficulty performing a particular movement.

That difficulty might be influenced by strength, coordination, mobility, experience, task familiarity, or some combination of factors.

I can't reliably determine all of those influences simply by watching one repetition.

What I can do is use the athlete's response to guide further observation.

I might change one condition and see what happens.

I might observe another repetition under the same conditions.

I might compare the athlete's response across related tasks.

Those observations may help me better understand the difficulty, but they don't automatically establish its cause.

This is why I treat evaluation during training as an ongoing process rather than a final judgment based on one attempt.

Observation provides information. Coaching requires deciding what that information means and what to do with it.

Better Performance During Practice Isn't Always Learning

There is another distinction I consider important.

An athlete may perform a drill better after several repetitions.

That improvement is useful to observe.

But improved performance during a practice session doesn't necessarily mean the athlete has developed a lasting movement capability.

Sometimes performance improves because the athlete has become more familiar with the immediate task.

Sometimes the improvement depends on a particular instruction or practice condition.

Whether the athlete can reproduce that improvement later, or apply it in a different movement situation, is a separate question.

In motor-learning research, this distinction between performance during practice and relatively lasting learning is important.

That's why I don't assume that one successful repetition, or even several improved repetitions, proves that a movement has been learned.

I want to see whether the athlete can demonstrate the movement again.

And when appropriate, I want to see how the movement holds up as the task demands change.

Within the Speed Progression, that may involve observing the athlete during later drills that introduce different starting positions, support conditions, or movement demands.

Those observations provide additional information.

They don't automatically prove that improvement in one drill has transferred to competitive sprint performance.

Improvement during practice is encouraging. Demonstrating that the improvement persists is a different matter.

Coaching Is an Ongoing Exchange of Information

When an athlete performs a drill, two things are happening.

The athlete is responding to a movement problem.

And I'm learning something about that response.

What I observe influences my next coaching decision.

That decision influences the conditions under which the athlete practices again.

The next repetition provides more information.

Sometimes I intervene.

Sometimes I don't.

Sometimes the athlete discovers a more effective movement strategy without needing me to explain it.

Other times, a specific adjustment helps them accomplish something they couldn't accomplish before.

The important thing is that I'm not treating each repetition as an isolated exercise to complete.

I'm using the practice process to better understand how the athlete moves and what they may need next.

Evaluation and training don't always have to occur separately.

They can be part of the same ongoing coaching process.

And that's one of the central ideas behind the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.


Research and Further Reading

The following publications provide scientific background on motor learning, feedback during practice, and the distinction between immediate performance and lasting skill development. They do not directly validate the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

  1. Kantak, S. S., & Winstein, C. J. (2012). Learning–performance distinction and memory processes for motor skills: A focused review and perspective. Behavioural Brain Research, 228(1), 219–231. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2011.11.028
  2. Winstein, C. J., & Schmidt, R. A. (1990). Reduced frequency of knowledge of results enhances motor skill learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 16(4), 677–691. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-7393.16.4.677
  3. Wulf, G., Shea, C., & Lewthwaite, R. (2010). Motor skill learning and performance: A review of influential factors. Medical Education, 44(1), 75–84. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03421.x

About the Author

Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

Coach Michael Johnson is a Doctor of Physical Therapy, Certified Athletic Trainer, and Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist. A longtime coach across multiple sports, he has spent years developing and refining practical approaches to athletic movement, speed development, and performance training.

He is the developer of the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression, a nine-drill coaching system designed to introduce, develop, and progressively integrate movement components involved in athletic starting mechanics and acceleration.