Before I Tell an Athlete What to Do, I Want to See What They Do (Coaching Principle 6)

Why an athlete's first attempt can reveal information that detailed instructions might otherwise conceal.

By Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

When I introduce an athlete to a new movement, one of the first decisions I make is how much information to give them before they begin.

I want the athlete to understand what they're being asked to accomplish.

But I don't necessarily want to explain exactly how they should accomplish it.

There's a difference.

If I describe every body position, every movement, and every detail of the technique before the athlete's first attempt, I've already influenced how they're going to approach the task.

That may be appropriate in some circumstances.

But it also means I've lost an opportunity to observe how the athlete might have approached the movement without those instructions.

Sometimes I want to see what an athlete does before I tell them how to do it.

That idea plays an important role in how I approach the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

Explain the Task Without Supplying the Solution

When an athlete encounters an unfamiliar movement problem, they need enough information to understand what they're supposed to accomplish.

They may need to know where to begin, what action to perform, when to initiate movement, or what conditions must be maintained.

Those instructions establish the task.

But there's a difference between establishing the task and explaining every movement the athlete should use to complete it.

Suppose I want to observe how an athlete initiates movement from a particular starting position.

I can establish the starting position and explain the objective.

Or I can go further and tell the athlete exactly how to position their body, which limb to move first, how to distribute their weight, and how to organize the movements that follow.

Those two approaches may produce different responses.

Neither is automatically wrong.

But they provide different information.

With detailed instructions, I'm observing how the athlete performs a movement I've already helped organize.

With fewer instructions, I may learn more about how the athlete initially approaches the problem.

I want to provide the information necessary to understand the task without automatically supplying every part of the solution.

The First Attempt Can Be Informative

An athlete's first attempt at an unfamiliar movement can tell me something about how they currently approach that task.

What do they do first?

How do they organize their body?

What movement strategy do they choose?

What happens when the movement begins?

Do they accomplish the intended objective?

The answers may help guide my next coaching decision.

Sometimes an athlete organizes the movement effectively without much instruction.

Sometimes the response reveals a movement characteristic that deserves additional attention.

And sometimes the athlete simply needs another opportunity to become familiar with the task.

But I want to be careful about what I conclude.

An athlete's first response isn't necessarily their best response.

It also isn't a complete assessment of their physical capabilities.

Their movement may be influenced by prior experience, unfamiliarity, uncertainty about the task, or the conditions under which the attempt occurs.

That's why I treat the first attempt as information, not a final judgment.

The first attempt doesn't tell me everything about the athlete. It gives me somewhere to begin.

Instructions Change What I'm Observing

One reason I pay attention to how much instruction I provide is that instructions themselves can influence movement.

If I tell an athlete to focus on a particular body part, they may organize their movement around that instruction.

If I prescribe a specific sequence, they may attempt to reproduce that sequence.

If I demonstrate a movement and ask them to imitate it, I may be observing their ability to reproduce what they've seen.

Those responses can be useful.

There are times when imitation, detailed instruction, or specific technical feedback is exactly what I want.

But I need to recognize that I've changed the conditions of the task.

I'm no longer observing the same response I might have seen without those instructions.

This matters because I don't want to mistake an athlete's ability to follow my directions for an independent ability to organize the movement.

Those are related, but they aren't necessarily the same thing.

How I explain a movement can influence the movement I eventually observe.

More Instruction Isn't Always Better

Coaches often want to help athletes succeed.

One way we try to help is by providing more information.

We explain the movement.

We demonstrate it.

We identify the positions we want.

We describe what should happen next.

Sometimes that information is necessary and useful.

But more information isn't automatically better information.

An athlete who receives too many instructions at once may have difficulty determining which details matter most.

And when I explain every part of the movement before the athlete has attempted it, I may remove opportunities for the athlete to organize parts of the solution independently.

That doesn't mean I should withhold useful instruction.

It means I should consider whether the information I'm providing is necessary at that moment.

What does the athlete need to understand before beginning?

What information can I obtain by observing an attempt?

What might be more useful to explain after I've seen the athlete respond?

The answers may differ depending on the athlete, the drill, and the movement being addressed.

The objective isn't to provide as little instruction as possible. It's to provide the instruction that serves the purpose of the task.

The Amount of Guidance Changes Throughout the Progression

The IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression is organized so that different drills introduce different movement problems.

Some drills deliberately limit what the athlete can do.

They establish specific starting conditions or constrain movement so that particular components can be introduced and practiced.

In those situations, the coach may need to provide more detailed instructions.

The constraints are part of what makes the drill useful.

As the progression advances, other drills give the athlete greater freedom to organize the movement.

Previously introduced components must be coordinated under different starting positions, support conditions, and movement demands.

Those situations provide opportunities to observe how the athlete responds without having every movement prescribed.

That doesn't mean the progression moves in a perfectly straight line from more instruction to less instruction.

A later drill may introduce a new constraint because that constraint serves a particular purpose.

And an athlete may still need additional instruction or feedback at any stage.

The important point is that the amount of guidance should reflect what the drill is intended to accomplish.

Sometimes I constrain the movement to develop a component. Other times, I want to see how the athlete organizes those components with greater independence.

Knowing When to Explain Is Part of Coaching

Observing before explaining doesn't mean allowing an athlete to attempt a task without understanding it.

It doesn't mean ignoring safety requirements.

And it doesn't mean withholding instructions that are essential to the drill.

Those conditions need to be established before the athlete begins.

But once the task is understood, I don't necessarily need to provide every technical detail.

I can observe the initial response.

I can allow another attempt.

I can provide a specific instruction when the athlete's response suggests it would be useful.

Or I can modify the task when the athlete needs a different movement problem.

The decision depends on what I'm trying to develop and what the athlete demonstrates.

There are times when detailed instruction is appropriate.

There are times when demonstration is useful.

And there are times when the athlete's own response provides more valuable information than another explanation from me.

Knowing when to explain—and when to observe—is part of the coaching process.

Give the Athlete an Opportunity to Show You

When I introduce a new movement, I want to understand how the athlete approaches it.

If I explain every part of the solution before the first attempt, I may never see that initial response.

That doesn't make detailed instruction wrong.

It simply changes what I'm evaluating.

Within the Speed Progression, I want to use instruction deliberately.

Sometimes I need to establish specific conditions.

Sometimes I need to guide a movement component.

Sometimes I need to provide feedback.

And sometimes I need to give the athlete enough information to understand the task, then allow them to show me how they approach it.

That initial response can help determine what happens next.

Before I tell an athlete exactly how to move, I want to consider what I might learn by watching them try.


Research and Further Reading

The following publications provide scientific background on motor-learning instructions, demonstrations, attentional focus, and how pre-practice information influences movement organization. They do not directly validate the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

  1. Hodges, N. J., & Franks, I. M. (2002). Modelling coaching practice: The role of instruction and demonstration. Journal of Sports Sciences, 20(10), 793–811. https://doi.org/10.1080/026404102320675648
  2. Wulf, G., Höß, M., & Prinz, W. (1998). Instructions for motor learning: Differential effects of internal versus external focus of attention. Journal of Motor Behavior, 30(2), 169–179. https://doi.org/10.1080/00222899809601334
  3. Hodges, N. J., & Franks, I. M. (2002). Learning as a function of coordination bias: Building upon pre-practice behaviours. Human Movement Science, 21(2), 231–258. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-9457(02)00101-X

About the Author

Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

Coach Michael Johnson is a Doctor of Physical Therapy, Certified Athletic Trainer, and Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist. A longtime coach across multiple sports, he has spent years developing and refining practical approaches to athletic movement, speed development, and performance training.

He is the developer of the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression, a nine-drill coaching system designed to introduce, develop, and progressively integrate movement components involved in athletic starting mechanics and acceleration.