More Repetitions Don't Always Mean More Learning

Why I want athletes to recognize and reproduce movement, not simply repeat it.

By Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

When I'm coaching an athlete, I expect them to repeat movements.

Repetition is part of developing nearly every athletic skill.

Athletes need opportunities to experience a movement, become familiar with its demands, and develop the ability to reproduce it.

But I've never believed that simply completing more repetitions automatically means an athlete is learning more.

An athlete can perform the same drill repeatedly without necessarily improving their understanding or control of the movement.

They may become more comfortable with the task.

They may become better at following my instructions.

They may even demonstrate a temporary improvement in how the movement looks.

But those outcomes don't necessarily mean the athlete can recognize, reproduce, or adjust the movement independently.

The purpose of repetition isn't simply to repeat the movement. It's to develop the athlete's ability to perform it.

That's an important distinction in how I approach the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

Repetition Creates Opportunities for Learning

When an athlete encounters a new movement, the task may initially feel unfamiliar.

They may not know exactly how to organize their body.

They may have difficulty recognizing the timing or sequence of particular actions.

They may need several attempts simply to become comfortable with the conditions of the drill.

Repetition gives them opportunities to experience those demands.

Each attempt exposes the athlete to information about the movement.

They experience how their body responds, how the movement develops, and what happens when they organize the task in a particular way.

Over time, those experiences can contribute to improved coordination and movement control.

But repetition doesn't guarantee that improvement.

An athlete might repeat a movement without making meaningful progress.

They might continue using a strategy that interferes with the intended objective.

Or they might become very familiar with a drill without developing the ability to perform it effectively under different conditions.

That's why I don't evaluate practice simply by counting repetitions.

Repetitions provide opportunities for learning. What the athlete develops through those repetitions is what matters.

Familiarity Is Important, but It Isn't the Same as Learning

One of the first things repetition can provide is familiarity.

The athlete becomes accustomed to the starting position, the movement demands, and the sequence of events involved in the drill.

What initially seemed unfamiliar may become more comfortable.

The athlete may begin performing the task with less hesitation.

They may require fewer explanations simply because they understand what the drill involves.

Those changes can be useful.

But familiarity doesn't necessarily mean the athlete has developed the movement capability I'm trying to establish.

An athlete can know exactly what a drill requires and still have difficulty performing it.

They can recognize the starting position, understand the instructions, and anticipate what happens next without consistently organizing the movement effectively.

That's why I distinguish between becoming familiar with a task and becoming proficient at performing it.

Knowing what a movement involves isn't the same as being able to perform it well.

I Want to Know What the Athlete Experienced

One way I learn about an athlete's developing understanding is by asking questions.

Sometimes, after a repetition, I'll ask:

“What happened?”

“What did you feel?”

“What do you think you did wrong?”

I'm not necessarily looking for a detailed technical explanation.

I want to understand what the athlete noticed about the movement they just performed.

Did they recognize how they initiated the action?

Did they notice a change in their body position?

Did they feel that one attempt was different from another?

Can they identify something that may have interfered with the intended movement?

Their answers provide information I can't obtain simply by watching.

I can observe the athlete's movement, but I can't automatically know what they perceived while performing it.

Sometimes their description matches what I observed.

Sometimes it doesn't.

And sometimes their answer reveals that they were paying attention to something entirely different from what I expected.

That information can influence how I coach the next repetition.

I want to know not only what the athlete did, but also what they recognized about what they did.

Feeling Something Doesn't Mean Understanding It

An athlete's perception of a movement is useful information, but it isn't necessarily accurate information.

An athlete may tell me that a repetition felt better even when the movement didn't improve in the way I intended.

They may believe they performed a particular action when my observation suggests otherwise.

Or they may recognize that something felt different without understanding what caused the difference.

That's not unusual.

Movement perception and movement performance are related, but they aren't identical.

Part of the coaching process involves helping the athlete develop a more useful understanding of what they're experiencing.

Sometimes I can do that by asking another question.

Sometimes I provide feedback that helps the athlete compare their perception with what actually occurred.

And sometimes another repetition provides the opportunity to recognize a difference they hadn't noticed before.

But I don't assume that an athlete has developed accurate movement awareness simply because they can describe how something felt.

Recognizing a sensation isn't necessarily the same as recognizing what happened mechanically.

From Following Instructions to Recognizing Movement

Early in the learning process, an athlete may depend heavily on my instructions.

I establish the task.

I identify a movement characteristic that needs attention.

I provide a cue or adjustment.

The athlete performs another repetition.

Initially, much of the process may depend on my ability to recognize the problem and communicate what I want.

But I don't want that relationship to remain entirely one-sided.

As the athlete gains experience, I want to provide opportunities for them to recognize relevant characteristics of their own movement.

Instead of immediately identifying every problem, I may ask what they noticed.

Instead of automatically repeating the same cue, I may allow them another attempt without it.

I want to see whether they can recognize the intended movement and reproduce it with less assistance.

That doesn't mean every athlete will develop those abilities at the same rate.

And it doesn't mean that repetition alone will make the athlete independent.

But increasing independence is one of the objectives I'm working toward.

I don't want the athlete to become good only at following my corrections. I want them to develop the ability to recognize and organize the movement themselves.

Recognizing a Problem and Correcting It Are Different Abilities

An athlete may recognize that something went wrong without knowing how to change it.

They might accurately describe a movement problem after a repetition.

They may even identify the same issue I observed.

But that doesn't necessarily mean they can correct it during the next attempt.

Recognition and correction are different capabilities.

The athlete may need additional practice, a different instruction, or a change in the conditions of the drill before they can produce the intended movement.

Likewise, an athlete may perform a movement effectively without being able to explain exactly how they accomplished it.

I don't require every athlete to describe their movement in biomechanical terms.

What matters is whether they can increasingly perform the intended task and, when appropriate, recognize information that helps them regulate their performance.

Being able to explain a movement isn't the same as being able to perform it. And recognizing an error isn't the same as being able to correct it.

Not Every Repetition Needs a Conversation

Asking athletes to evaluate their performance can be useful.

But that doesn't mean I need to stop after every repetition and ask them to explain what happened.

Sometimes the athlete needs another opportunity to perform the movement without interruption.

Sometimes I want them focused on accomplishing the task rather than consciously analyzing every part of their body.

And sometimes the movement is developing effectively enough that additional discussion would serve little purpose.

The questions are tools.

I use them when I believe they will provide useful information or help the athlete recognize something meaningful.

I don't want the practice session to become a continuous conversation about technique.

Just as more repetitions don't automatically produce more learning, more analysis doesn't automatically produce better movement.

Purposeful practice doesn't require the athlete to consciously evaluate every repetition.

Can the Athlete Perform Without My Reminder?

One question I consider as an athlete progresses is whether they can perform the movement without needing the same instruction every time.

Suppose I provide a cue and the athlete responds appropriately.

That's useful.

But if the athlete needs to hear that cue before every repetition, I need to consider how independently they can organize the movement.

At some point, I may deliberately withhold the reminder and observe what happens.

Can the athlete reproduce the intended action?

Do they recognize when the movement differs from previous attempts?

Can they make an appropriate adjustment without waiting for me to identify the problem?

Those observations provide information about the athlete's developing capabilities.

I also recognize that performing a movement successfully without a reminder during one practice session doesn't establish lasting learning.

I need to consider whether the movement can be reproduced later and under different task conditions.

But reducing dependence on constant external correction is a meaningful coaching objective.

I want to know whether the athlete can perform the movement, not just whether they can perform it when I remind them how.

Repetition Should Develop More Than Familiarity

Throughout the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression, repetition gives athletes opportunities to experience movement problems under different conditions.

Some drills introduce specific components.

Others require previously introduced components to be coordinated within more demanding tasks.

As the athlete progresses, I want to observe more than their ability to complete the assigned repetitions.

I want to know whether they're becoming familiar with the movement.

Whether they can increasingly recognize relevant characteristics of their performance.

Whether they can reproduce the intended movement.

And whether they're developing greater independence from my instructions and corrections.

Those outcomes won't necessarily develop at the same time.

An athlete may become familiar with a drill before they can perform it consistently.

They may recognize a problem before they can correct it.

And they may perform a movement effectively before they can explain what they're doing.

That's part of why coaching requires continued observation and adjustment.

The number of repetitions tells me how much practice occurred. It doesn't tell me everything the athlete learned.

Repetition With a Purpose

Repetition is essential to how I develop athletic movement.

But I don't want repetition to become an exercise in simply accumulating volume.

I want athletes to experience movement, become familiar with its demands, and develop the ability to reproduce it.

When appropriate, I want them to recognize what happened during an attempt.

I want them to become increasingly capable of identifying meaningful differences between repetitions.

And over time, I want them to become less dependent on me to recognize and correct every movement problem.

That doesn't mean every repetition needs a correction, a question, or a technical explanation.

Sometimes the most useful thing I can do is allow the athlete another opportunity to perform the task.

What matters is that the repetitions serve a developmental purpose.

Repetition should develop familiarity, recognition, and the ability to perform—not simply add to the number of attempts completed.

That's how I approach repetition within the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.


Research and Further Reading

The following publications provide scientific background on movement variability, error estimation, feedback, and motor skill acquisition. They help explain how practice can contribute to developing movement capability and awareness. They do not directly validate the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression or its specific coaching questions.

  1. Dhawale, A. K., Smith, M. A., & Ölveczky, B. P. (2017). The role of variability in motor learning. Annual Review of Neuroscience, 40, 479–498. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-neuro-072116-031548
  2. Barros, J. A. C., Yantha, Z. D., Carter, M. J., Hussien, J., & Ste-Marie, D. M. (2019). Examining the impact of error estimation on the effects of self-controlled feedback. Human Movement Science, 63, 182–198. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.humov.2018.12.002
  3. Wulf, G., Shea, C., & Lewthwaite, R. (2010). Motor skill learning and performance: A review of influential factors. Medical Education, 44(1), 75–84. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03421.x

About the Author

Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

Coach Michael Johnson is a Doctor of Physical Therapy, Certified Athletic Trainer, and Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist. A longtime coach across multiple sports, he has spent years developing and refining practical approaches to athletic movement, speed development, and performance training.

He is the developer of the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression, a nine-drill coaching system designed to introduce, develop, and progressively integrate movement components involved in athletic starting mechanics and acceleration.