Just Because I See It Doesn't Mean I Need to Correct It (Coaching Principle 7)

Why effective coaching requires deciding which movement problems deserve attention first.

By Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

When I watch an athlete perform a movement, I can usually identify several things that could be different.

A body position might not be what I expected.

The athlete might initiate movement differently than I intended.

The timing or coordination of certain movements might appear inconsistent.

And sometimes several of those things happen during the same repetition.

The temptation is to correct everything.

But just because I can identify a movement difference doesn't mean that difference requires correction.

And even when several things need attention, that doesn't mean I should address all of them at once.

My job isn't to correct everything I see. It's to determine what matters most to the movement I'm trying to develop.

That's an important part of how I approach coaching within the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

Not Every Difference Is a Problem

Athletes don't all move identically.

They differ in their body proportions, strength, mobility, coordination, experience, and physical capabilities.

Those differences can influence how they accomplish the same movement task.

As a coach, I need to recognize that an athlete's movement may look different from what I expected without necessarily being ineffective.

A different joint position, movement sequence, or strategy doesn't automatically represent something that needs to be corrected.

The first question I ask is whether the athlete is accomplishing the intended purpose of the drill.

If they are, I need a reason before trying to change how they accomplish it.

If they aren't, I need to determine which characteristics of their movement may be interfering with that objective.

A movement difference becomes important when it affects something that matters to the task.

That doesn't mean every difference affecting the task requires immediate correction.

It means I have a reason to investigate it further.

Several Problems Don't Require Several Corrections

Sometimes an athlete demonstrates several movement characteristics that deserve attention.

One position may be inappropriate for the intended movement.

Another action may occur at the wrong time.

A third characteristic may interfere with how the athlete transitions into the next movement.

I could attempt to correct all three.

I could explain each problem, describe the desired positions, and give the athlete several instructions to remember during the next repetition.

But that creates another challenge.

Now the athlete must attempt the movement while also trying to consciously manage several technical instructions.

Depending on the athlete and the task, that additional information may make the movement more difficult to organize.

It also makes my next observation harder to interpret.

If the athlete performs better, which instruction helped?

If the athlete performs worse, which instruction created the difficulty?

I may not know.

That's why I generally prefer to identify one meaningful issue and address it first.

When several things need attention, I don't necessarily need to address them all at the same time.

Decide What Matters Most

Choosing a correction requires more than identifying something that looks wrong.

I need to consider the purpose of the drill.

What movement characteristic am I trying to introduce or develop?

Which observed problem most directly interferes with that objective?

Is the problem preventing the athlete from accomplishing the task?

Could another repetition provide useful information before I intervene?

Those questions help me decide where to direct my attention.

For example, suppose a drill is intended to help an athlete organize movement from a particular starting position.

I may observe several differences in how the athlete performs it.

But if one characteristic prevents the athlete from accomplishing the primary movement objective, that characteristic may deserve attention before the others.

Addressing it may also change other parts of the movement.

A problem I initially observed might become less significant or disappear altogether.

That doesn't mean I should assume one correction will automatically solve several problems.

It means I should observe what happens before deciding what else needs attention.

The most noticeable difference isn't always the most important one.

One Correction, Another Repetition, Then Reassess

When I decide that a correction is appropriate, I generally want to keep it focused.

I identify the movement characteristic I want to influence.

I provide an instruction, modify a condition, or make another deliberate adjustment intended to address it.

Then I give the athlete another opportunity to perform the drill.

What happened?

Did the movement characteristic change?

Did the athlete accomplish the intended task more effectively?

Did something else change that I wasn't expecting?

Do I need another repetition before drawing a conclusion?

The answers help determine my next coaching decision.

This is an ongoing process.

I observe, identify a priority, intervene when appropriate, and reassess.

Sometimes the initial correction is sufficient.

Sometimes another issue becomes the next priority.

And sometimes the athlete's response tells me that my original interpretation was incomplete.

One useful correction. Another repetition. Then reassess.

That approach keeps the coaching process responsive to what the athlete actually demonstrates.

A Changed Movement Doesn't Always Prove the Correction Worked

There's an important limitation to this approach.

Suppose I provide one instruction and the athlete's next repetition looks better.

It's tempting to conclude that my instruction caused the improvement.

It may have contributed.

But other factors could also influence the response.

The athlete may have become more familiar with the movement.

They may have organized the task differently simply because they had another opportunity.

Normal variation between repetitions may also play a role.

Even when I change only one thing, I can't automatically establish that the change caused the result.

What I can do is continue observing.

Does the improvement appear again?

Does the athlete demonstrate it without another reminder?

Does the movement remain effective when the task conditions change?

Those observations may increase my confidence that the adjustment was useful.

But I still need to distinguish an immediate change in performance from evidence of lasting motor learning.

A better repetition gives me information. It doesn't necessarily give me proof.

Sometimes the Priority Is to Wait

Identifying a movement problem doesn't always mean I need to correct it immediately.

Sometimes the athlete is encountering a movement for the first time.

Sometimes another repetition may help them become more familiar with the task.

Sometimes I want to see whether a particular movement characteristic persists before deciding how to address it.

In those situations, allowing another attempt without additional instruction can be a deliberate coaching decision.

That doesn't mean ignoring a problem that prevents the athlete from performing the task safely or effectively.

And it doesn't mean that repetition alone will always resolve the issue.

It means I want to distinguish between something that deserves my attention and something that requires an immediate intervention.

Deciding what to correct also means deciding when to correct it.

Coaching Shouldn't Become a Checklist

It's possible to approach athletic movement as a list of positions and actions that every athlete must reproduce.

The coach observes the athlete.

The coach identifies everything that differs from the list.

Then the coach attempts to correct each difference.

But movement isn't always that simple.

Athletes may accomplish the same task using somewhat different strategies.

One change can influence several other parts of the movement.

And the significance of a particular movement characteristic depends on what the athlete is trying to accomplish.

That's why I don't want my coaching to become a process of checking off every technical detail.

I want to understand the purpose of the movement.

I want to recognize which characteristics matter to that purpose.

And when I decide to intervene, I want to address something meaningful rather than simply something noticeable.

The next repetition may change what I decide to address next.

Effective coaching isn't about finding the greatest number of things to correct. It's about making useful decisions about what deserves attention.

Correct What Matters

When I observe an athlete, I may see several things I could change.

Some may be meaningful problems.

Some may be acceptable individual differences.

Others may become less important as the athlete gains experience with the movement.

I don't need to respond to all of them at once.

I need to determine which characteristics matter to the purpose of the drill and decide whether an intervention is appropriate.

If I make a correction, I want to observe what happens next.

If I allow another repetition without correcting anything, I still want to observe what happens next.

Either decision should serve a purpose.

Correct what matters, not everything you see.

That's how I approach corrective feedback within the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.


Research and Further Reading

The following publications provide scientific background on attentional focus, augmented feedback, and motor learning. They help explain why the content and timing of coaching feedback deserve careful consideration. They do not directly validate the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression.

  1. Wulf, G. (2013). Attentional focus and motor learning: A review of 15 years. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 6(1), 77–104. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2012.723728
  2. McKay, B., Hussien, J., Vinh, M.-A., Mir-Orefice, A., Brooks, H., & Ste-Marie, D. M. (2022). Meta-analysis of the reduced relative feedback frequency effect on motor learning and performance. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 61, Article 102165. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2022.102165
  3. Petancevski, E. L., Inns, J., Fransen, J., & Impellizzeri, F. M. (2022). The effect of augmented feedback on the performance and learning of gross motor and sport-specific skills: A systematic review. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 63, Article 102277. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2022.102277

About the Author

Michael Johnson, DPT, ATC, STC, CSCS

Coach Michael Johnson is a Doctor of Physical Therapy, Certified Athletic Trainer, and Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist. A longtime coach across multiple sports, he has spent years developing and refining practical approaches to athletic movement, speed development, and performance training.

He is the developer of the IGNITE BLOX Speed Progression, a nine-drill coaching system designed to introduce, develop, and progressively integrate movement components involved in athletic starting mechanics and acceleration.